10 Ways to Upgrade Your Crowd Work

(Comedy Mindhacks #41)

Hey, Friends! I’m stoked to share this co-authored article on crowd work with you. I’ve written it with my pal, Mike Lukas, who’s a well-known comedian and content creator. He’ll appear on the “Messed-Up to Set-Ups” podcast soon, so stay tuned for that. In the meantime, give this article a read, check out Mike’s site HERE, and give him a follow.

---

It used to be that when a comedian worked the crowd at a show, it was to stall or to add time, not to create post worthy content like it is nowadays. Creating live improvised humor using drunk strangers is a job skill for the pro comic at the highest levels, mostly because in the hands of a newbie crowd work can be an embarrassing waste of time. For those comedians hoping to add crowd work skills to their humor toolbelt, here are ten ways to improve your people-riffing technique.

1) Get Names
Lukas: Names are the cheat code of crowd work. The second you remember someone’s name, you’ve made them part of the show. Use names in callbacks, weave them into bits, give them nicknames that stick. When you call back “Brenda from Accounting” ten minutes later, the room explodes — because it feels personal. You’ve created an inside joke shared only by the people in that room, on that night. That’s what live comedy’s all about.

Halcomb: Names are like currency in crowd work. It’s pretty obvious that most people love hearing their name. It makes them feel seen, remembered, and part of the show. As soon as you use their name, you’ve got their attention and, more than likely, everyone else’s. Take advantage of this simple trick.

2) Listen to Your Audience
Lukas: There’s gold in what these strangers say — not just what they say, but how, why, and when they say it. Listen like a detective on caffeine. Every odd phrase, pause, or tone shift is a clue. Make up motives if you have to. Build your jokes from those “facts.” When you call something back later, it feels spontaneous — but it only works because you were paying attention. Think of their words as Lego bricks. You’re just building the funnier castle.

Halcomb: Listen for the first unusual thing. Listen kinda like you’re a mother-in-law trying to catch her daughter-in-law in a lie. Does their voice crack? Do they have a nervous laugh? Do they have a way of over-explaining/giving too much information? Whatever the first unusual thing is, latch on to that. Crowd work is first about listening, then diagnosing, then responding.

3) Repeat Whatever They Say
Lukas: Never assume the rest of the audience heard that one drunk in row three. Repeat their line into the mic — it buys you time, brings everyone in, and gives you a setup to punch. Even better, abbreviate or misquote them slightly for laughs. “Oh, you said you’re an influencer? Translation: unemployed but photogenic.” Repeating keeps control while still making them feel seen — and makes sure you stay the funny one in the exchange.

Halcomb: Repeating what someone says does several things: it makes them feel heard, it lets the rest of the crowd in, and it gives you a few glorious seconds to think. It also allows you to say the statement out loud, which gives you a shot at either a) Putting extra stress on the first unusual thing you noticed, or b) Noticing the first unusual thing if you missed it the first time around.

4) “Yes, And” Whatever They Say
Lukas: The rookie move is to roast or reject. The pro move? Agree and heighten. “Yes, and” doesn’t just apply to improv — it’s the engine of great crowd work. If they say something weird, agree like it’s gospel and then twist it into absurdity. You’ll create a shared world built around that person’s energy, and the crowd will love that you didn’t shut them down. Agreement opens doors. Judgment slams them.

Halcomb: Crowd work stalls or dies the moment you treat the person in the crowd as an opponent (even if they are a “heckler”) and start trying to “win” against them. But with crowd work, you’re not trying to prove how smart you are to the audience or that you’re smarter than the crowd member you’re engaging; instead, you’re simply proving to everyone that you’re listening. So, start by affirming what the person said (the “yes” part), then build on it (the “and” part). For example, imagine a guy in the
audience has been a bit loud so you engage him. You ask him what he does and he tells you he’s a firefighter. You acknowledge it/affirm it (the “yes” part)! Then you respond with some variation (the “and” part) of, “And... that explains why you’re burning through my patience.” Maybe you follow-up with, “Sir, it’s like you saw a crowd enjoying themselves in here tonight and thought... ‘Not while I’m on duty!’”

5) Ask Questions That Lead to Your Material
Lukas: Smart crowd work looks improvised. Secretly, it’s planned. Ask questions that can pivot into your written material. For example, if your next bit is about dating, ask couples in the crowd how they met. The audience thinks it’s random — you know it’s a perfect alley-oop to your next joke. The trick is to connect your curiosity to your content. That’s how you “yes-and” your way into pre-written gold.

Halcomb: Sometimes crowd work lines up perfectly with your material, and when it does, that can be such a gift. Sometimes it doesn’t. Here are a few ways to approach it: a) Thought out: you’ve planned for every possible answer, which is great until someone says something you never saw coming; b) 100% spontaneous: it’ll always feel real, but it might also bomb spectacularly; and, c) Thought about but not completely thought through. I think that’s the sweet spot. Here you’re listening, reacting, and building in real time. You’re not forcing it; you’re following it. And if it can dovetail into your material, that’s great.

6) Control the Conversation by Controlling the Tempo
Lukas: Crowd work is a dance — but you’re the one leading. You’ve got the mic, so you set the rhythm. Keep the pace tight enough to hold their attention but loose enough to feel real. If you let them ramble, the moment dies in the weeds. If you cut them off too fast, you look defensive. Control the beat like a drummer who knows exactly when to hit the snare. Let them step, but make sure you’re the one calling the next move.

Halcomb: Set the rhythm and maintain control over it. The moment you let a drunk woman dictate the tempo of the show or your set, you’ve just turned into a bad emcee. Part of controlling the tempo has to do with being playful. If you’re too intense or aggressive, it’ll kill the tempo. If you’re taking too long to respond, it will not end will. If you’re letting people in the crowd take over or talk over you, it’ll frustrate audience members. Keep the momentum on your side by being playful, even when others might seem to be getting out of control.

7) Use Silence to Your Advantage
Lukas: Silence isn’t the enemy — it’s a weapon. Think of it as the negative space around the laugh. When you pause, the audience leans in. When you hold that tension, you own the room. Moments of quiet amplify everything that follows. A single well-timed pause can make a punchline hit like a sucker punch — or make a crowd erupt just from the relief of finally laughing again. Master your pauses and you’ll stop sounding like a comic chasing laughs, and start sounding like one controlling them.

Halcomb: Sometimes silence makes people nervous. That’s okay. It’s okay to let people sweat a little bit. Silence can be used to create and keep tension. It can also be used to draw attention to gestures. Even outside of crowd work, learning how to use silence effectively when telling a written joke is huge. Silence can make or break a joke. Don’t be afraid to take a few seconds (what often feels like an eternity when you’re in front of people!) to let the room settle and gather your thoughts. Also, sometimes an audience appreciates it when you give them a minute to catch their breath.

8) Build Mini Narratives
Lukas: Great crowd work feels like a short play you’re writing in real time. Every audience member becomes a character, and you’re the narrator stitching it all together. Name people, relationships, even fake backstories — give the crowd something to visualize. When you bring those details back later, it feels like a shared story everyone helped build. Then you can pivot seamlessly back to your act, using that mini-world you just created as a bridge to your next bit. Instant callbacks. Effortless transition. Big payoff.

Halcomb: In a way, crowd work is like SIMS in that it’s you engaging in world-building. By exaggerating and heightening and misunderstanding, you’re creating a world and lore. Yes, your crowd work began with an audience member but, once you start heightening, it’s almost like that audience member becomes a side character in a new universe you’re creating. The crazy part is: a room full of grown adults are totally willing to play along and, to a degree, suspend reality and just laugh. By building a partly fictitious world, you can immediately start drawing on things from within that world and keep the story going. You can add to the world, subtract from it, and shape it in whatever way serves your purpose(s).

9) Connect the Dots
Lukas: Crowd work is basically freestyle callback science. Every audience interaction is a puzzle piece — your job is to notice which ones fit together. Connect one person’s weird comment to someone else’s earlier story, or tie a random audience answer into one of your bits. That’s where the magic happens. The crowd thinks you’re improvising genius connections in real time (and maybe you are), but really, you’re just building bridges between islands of funny. The laughs get bigger because the world feels smaller — and you’re the architect of it all.

Halcomb: Some real magic in crowd work can happen when you start linking people together. Imagine a scenario where someone up front says they’re a teacher and later someone in the back says they dropped out of school. Boom! You’ve got tension and when you’ve got that, you can make up a story that connects the two. You weave the elements together into one big joke. Now the audience isn’t just watching you talk to random strangers; they’re watching you build a web they’re all stuck in together and, more often than not, they love it.

10) Record and Recycle Your Best Interactions
Lukas: If something crushes once, don’t leave it buried in that night’s set. Record your shows, log the gems, and build a little arsenal of go-to comebacks and setups. Then, when someone at your next gig says something similar, you’ve got a tested response ready to fire. The magic is making it look spontaneous again. That’s what separates the pro from the parrot.

Halcomb: Every great crowd moment should go straight into your vault and, at present at least, probably on your social media feeds. Save this and don’t hesitate to reuse it. Even if you recycle it word-for-word, that’s fine. If you want or need to modify it, that’s fine, too. But be like a pro sports team: watch and study your game film. Study your rhythm, timing, and tone. What made it hit? Crowd work is like jazz, but even jazz musicians rehearse their solos.

Crowd work isn’t just about riffing with strangers, it’s about transforming chaos into comedy. The best comics make it look effortless, but it’s actually a finely tuned mix of listening, control, rhythm, and fearless curiosity. Every exchange is an opportunity to find truth, tension, or just something beautifully stupid to laugh about together. Master these ten moves, and you’ll stop fearing spontaneous moments and start inviting them. Because when you’re confident enough to let the audience co-author the funny, that’s when you stop performing at them—and start performing with them.