Comedy: A Very Short Introduction
Connecting Theory with Reality (Comedy Resources #16)
Anyone who has ever consistently done stand-up has, at some point, had to try to figure out why one joke crushes at one place but dies a slow, painful death at another. For me, as a scholar and comedian, I love diving into the intricacies of all that. I want to understand why those things happen. I love analyzing when jokes work and why, but also when and why they don’t.
I’ve heard numerous people (channeling E. B. White’s statement whether they realize it or not) say something quite like him: “Explaining a joke is like dissecting a frog. You understand it better but the frog dies in the process.” The idea is, if you start pulling a joke apart and analyzing it, if you have to explain it, you risk killing it. But I completely disagree, which is why it’s sometimes strange to live life as both a comedian and scholar. The more I can dissect the ins and outs of a joke, the greater appreciation I have for it and its genius. That’s also why I like engaging academic journal articles and books about comedy.
I recently got ahold of Matthew Bevis’s book Comedy: A Very Short Introduction. It reads like a kind of guided tour through the mind of someone who has thought about comedy longer and harder than almost anyone besides me has patience for. He’s an scholar, too, and he’s at Oxford, which means he has the enviable skillset to take a fart joke and make it sound like its dwelling place is within a philosophy seminar. Even so, somehow, against all odds, it works. Bevis manages to connect the high-level theory with the messy reality of actually trying to get a laugh from real people on a random Thursday night. So, here are some key takeaways from Bevis’s volume.
Key Takeaway #1 - Study But Don’t Suffocate: One of the things from this book that sticks out to me is how Bevis frames comedy as something one has to take seriously without treating it like it’s sacred. That sounds like a small distinction, but it’s actually quite important. As a comedian, if I treat comedy like it’s too important, I tighten up and lose the very looseness that makes it work. If I don’t take it seriously at all, however, I’m bound to stay shallow and repetitive. I have to care enough to study it but not so much that I, like a needy wife, suffocate it. (My wife’s not needy, btw. Babe, if you’re reading this, that truly wasn’t about you at all.)
In this book, Bevis also pushes readers to see comedy as more than just something comedians do on stage. It’s not just a performance, not at all; rather, like scoliosis, it’s a posture toward the world. Throughout the book, Bevis moves from Shakespeare to silent film to modern stand-up without acting like those are separate conversations. And, as he does, it starts to feel like comedy is less about writing jokes and more about noticing where things don’t quite line up. That’s kind of the anthem of my life really and I’m always up for a reminder that helps me pay attention to the small fractures in everyday life…the “messed-up” things, as I call them.
Key Takeaway #2 - Embrace What’s Messed-Up: While this is my wording, not his, the point is nevertheless the same. There’s a moment, for instance, where Bevis creatively describes comedy as putting one’s shoes on the wrong feet. When a person does that, everything still works, but it feels off in a way they just can’t ignore. I love that because that image is way stickier than any formal definition I’ve heard. It’s a great reminder that humor often shows up in subtle discomforts, in slight misalignments between what should be and what is. Or, as I frequently say on this site and in my podcasts, in the gap between expectation and reality.
As Bevis moves through different ideas, he starts getting into what I would actually call usable material, even if he never labels it that way. He talks about comedy as a kind of sanctioned indecency, which sounds academic until I realize that’s basically what I’m doing every time I step on stage. It’s similar to Jared Volle’s phrase “playful inappropriateness.” When I’m performing even as a clean comedian, I’m saying things I probably shouldn’t say, but in a way that gives the audience permission to laugh at it. For me, it’s not at all about being edgy for the sake of it, but about disrupting the normal flow just enough to create a reaction.
Key Takeaway #3 - Let’s Get Physical: In this work, the physical side of comedy showed up in a way that kind of caught me off guard. Bevis highlights the role of the body and bodily awkwardness. When I think about the old black-and-white videos of Chaplin or Keaton, for instance, I see it immediately. I’m not nearly as physical or animated as them at this point, but it does show up in smaller ways in my own jokes. A pause, a look, a gesture, or a movement at just the right time and in just the right way can carry as much weight as a punchline. Sometimes, too, the body tells the joke before the words even get there.
Key Takeaway #4 - Timing Is About Control: The structural side of comedy, which is very much my jam, shows up in the concept of timing. When talking about timing were talking about building an expectation and then breaking it at the right moment. Bevis walks through how surprise works, noting how it depends on setting something up clearly enough that the audience thinks they know where it’s going, that is, guiding the audience to a conclusion, then pulling the rug out from under them at the last second. As every comedian knows, that’s absolutely critical for getting laughs.
Key Takeaway #5 - Humor Comes From the Hard Parts of Being Human: In my view, one aspect of the book that holds everything together is Bevis’s understanding of why we laugh in the first place. He keeps coming back to the connection between laughter and pain and between humor and the harder parts of being human. Part of my own comedy philosophy is “If it’s messed-up, it’s material.” For me, comedy doesn’t just distract from suffering but it legitimately and actually helps me deal with it. Some of my strongest and best jokes come from the overlap of something hurting just enough to matter and being funny enough to just laugh.
By the time I finished this book, I didn’t feel like I had a new set ready to go. That’s not what this book is for or about. Instead, what I had was a little bit of a clearer lens for looking at the work I’m already doing. It helped draw my attention more to patterns, assumptions, and the small shifts that help convert silence or hurt into laughter.
There are definitely moments where the book feels more like a lecture than something I can take straight to the stage, but that’s just fine by me. I welcome that. Some of the analysis is dense but, for those willing to brave the density, there’s value waiting on the other side. This isn’t a book that gives me quick fixes or easy formulas. It’s something readers have to sit with, something that works on them slowly. But if someone’s serious about getting better, not just funnier but sharper and more aware, then this kind of thinking matters and this kind of book matters.
Fact: The two biggest fears for any comedian are staring at a blank page without a punchline, and standing under a hot spotlight and completely forgetting the next joke. So, I built two completely online, self-paced courses to solve both of these problems permanently. Join the growing community of working comedians and first-timers who’ve already used these labs to completely bulletproof their sets:
The Joke Writer’s Lab: Stop guessing at what makes people laugh. In this self-paced, online course, you’ll get the tools to find your unique comedic persona and learn the exact mechanics of writing a bulletproof joke. Get it HERE.
The Comedian’s Memory Lab: Never blank on stage again!!! Learn my insider method to build and flawlessly memorize your entire set, whether you are doing 3 minutes at an open mic or headlining for an hour. Get it HERE.